Browse > Home / Rants / Community Organizing is Social Media

| Subcribe via RSS

Community Organizing is Social Media

September 4th, 2008 Posted in Rants

(I’ll warn you in advance, this is a politics-influenced rant, but it does relate to community issues!)

During last night’s keynote speech by Rudy Giuliani at the Republican National Convention, Giuliani poked at Barack Obama’s former work as a community organizer with a smirk. Giuliani was clearly implying that community organizing was a joke, an utter waste of time. The crowd at the event laughed alongside him long enough to make him pause his speech. During Sarah Palin’s acceptance speech, she took a swipe at Obama’s service. Again the crowd went nuts.

Classy.

Here’s a part of how Barack Obama described his supposedly foolish pursuit in 1990:

In return, organizing teaches as nothing else does the beauty and strength of everyday people. Through the songs of the church and the talk on the stoops, through the hundreds of individual stories of coming up from the South and finding any job that would pay, of raising families on threadbare budgets, of losing some children to drugs and watching others earn degrees and land jobs their parents could never aspire to — it is through these stories and songs of dashed hopes and powers of endurance, of ugliness and strife, subtlety and laughter, that organizers can shape a sense of community not only for others, but for themselves.

Sound familiar? It should; social media and online community building are based on the “beauty and strength of everyday people”. Those of us who believe in the power of social media generally believe that small groups can have grand impact. The social media wonks among us have taken company after company to task for ignoring or misunderstanding this reality, and I hope that we do the same in this case.

This post isn’t about politics. It’s a reminder to all of us that laughing at those working to change the world or their neighborhoods for the better is absolutely unacceptable. We don’t accept it from the companies we buy from and we shouldn’t accept it from the politicians that we vote for, whatever side they come down on.

UPDATE: In the comments below and around the punditsphere today by many Republican supporters that the laughter was directed not at the concept of community organization, but the fact that Obama is somehow foolish for including that in discussions of his experience. Personally, I don’t buy that in the slightest, but you can watch the video and judge for yourself.


  • Jake - I think you're right on the money, if you're saying that social media, social networking, Web 2.0, whatever you want to call it, will foster even more impact from groups - both large and small. Social networking online is almost the ultimate equalizer, yet also the ultimate test of democracy. It will cut both ways, giving rise to both more cabalization while also enabling even greater transparency in all walks of life, including business and politics. It will also make it easier to organize. Witness Barack Obama's amazing online and mobile technology use, that has acted as the engine to his campaign.

    And I am a lefty. And highly insulted by the Republicans. The spin from them now is that we - the "lefties" just don't get it: either don't get the "joke" - hahahaha - or don't "get" that Giuliani and Palin weren't denigrating community organizers....oh, no...just that Obama should not use his experience, etc etc as another commenter here tried to spin it. But, as you rightly pointed out, and as the actual speeches show, that's not what was said, or implied. With speechwriters as good as they had, you'd think they could have been clearer to just call Obama out on HIS experience. But they didn't have the balls to do that. So they resorted to insulting a whole, general group of very noble, hardworking, selfless people, community organizers.

    Nice to see you slap your commenters down, too, when they try to spin.

    www.community-organizer.com
  • Very nicely done. Good job.
  • David Flores
    I thought the same thing. You'll get trolled for your statement, but they're the ones that don't get it. Organizing people and getting them involved is actually one of the higher forms of democracy (small d intended). After all, without a public that's involved and engaged, there's no chance of governing anyone, which would make the job of governors moot. Then again, the GOP enjoys running for an elected position much more than it does governing an electorate.
  • me
    Do you really not get this, or are you pretending just to make a point? I'd like to think lefties are smart enough to understand the reason why the community organizing is a joke. And it's not because it's not good work. It's because Barack has no experience that qualifies him to be president. This community organizing doesn't make him fit for the presidency. But you already knew that.
  • Sadly, you didn't feel bold enough about your discussion to leave a real name which speaks volumes to your point.

    I'm no "leftie", but that doesn't matter really. That's not the issue here. Community organizing isn't a joke, nor is Obama's experience with it as it relates to his OVERALL experience. I really don't want to take this too political, but if he was doing this YESTERDAY that'd be one thing. But this was years ago and speaks to how he thinks and approaches problems, not what he has been doing. He has 4 years in the national Senate and 11 years in the Illinois state senate. Let's not pretend that he's just fallen off some potatoe truck.

    Besides that, while the spin of that sad, sad moment at the RNC might be that people were simply laughing at the experience in relation to the position, I think we all know better than that.

    But that's enough on the political side. Let's get back to the discussion of how this relations to online and offline community building.
  • By the way, watch the clip yourself:

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6mAAxCg2CC4

    Rudy says "He worked as a community organizer", crowd laughs.
  • Pat
    So...a Community Organizer put together block parties and picnics? What is a CO?
  • All due respect, let's not be ignorant. Do you honestly think that we're debating the activites of a block party planner?

    Googling "What does a Community Organizer do?" returns several helpful links:

    http://tinyurl.com/5gg4ba
    http://tinyurl.com/5rz255

    ...are just two such links. Here's the best answer I've seen:

    "A community organizer does things for the people that the mayor, the city council, and other politicians and public officials can't or won't do."


    Union leaders could be considering "community organizers", FYI. Unions like the one Palin's husband is a member of.
  • Interesting rant Jake. I hope more people caught those swipes taken against community organizing by Giuliani and Palin. It was disheartening to hear those in power who are seeking more power to belittle the people and the people's efforts.

    This is the part of the movie where the people figure out that power, influence, and ideas can be taken away and redistributed through effort and engagement.

    Sounds to me like the very definition of Social Media.
  • Beautifully said. (Both of you)
  • Totally! My colleague posted a tweet about it here: http://twitter.com/libraryman/statuses/908911746
blog comments powered by Disqus