Browse > Home / Archive: March 2005

| Subcribe via RSS

The real change

There seemed to be an undercurrent at the Summit of “how can we use WOM techniques to sell crappy products”. No one wanted to admit it, but there were plenty of agency people asking questions that gave away that their thoughts were heading that way.


One of the panelists (can’t recall who but I think it was Dave Evans) was telling a story about those eye glass repair kits that are sold on late night TV. He was saying that not only do they not work, but they ruin your glasses. The greatest quote of the conference:


“The days of those kinds of products is are over…”


There are a metric ton of crap products, and probably always will be to some extent. But the power those once had is dwindling rapidly. Market forces are not necessarily squeezing them out, but certainly putting a governer on the amount.


But the key message to agencies trying to retain respect and do successful work? Stop taking crap clients.

WOMMA Summit finds

Couple interesting sites I came across at the WOMMA Summit.


http://www.bobquits.com


http://www.maryquits.com


http://www.fairenough.com/


 

WOMMA Summit Thoughts

March 31st, 2005 | Comments | Posted in Events and Speaking

I’m back from the WOMMA Summit, and it was a great time. As mentioned before, I was impressed with how many smart people I met. There were a ton of great presentations and honestly, I didn’t take a ton of notes about the presentations themselves. I was making notes mostly about things I was thinking of as I listened. Supposedly, I’ll be able to download the presentations soon, and then I’ll probably be posting even more.


I was on a panel with Coni from Discovery Education and Michael from the GM and the Fastlane blog. The focus was basically case studies from brands using community.


Michael mentioned that the GM blog is getting 4000-5000 visitors a day, with comment levels off the charts. 200 blogs from 45 countries are linking to it. Bob Lutz is blogging via his Blackberry, and sending it to someone to post. The vibe of the way the posts are written sometimes, that makes sense.


Interestingly, someone approached me after the panel and mentioned that I was being too humble about my community building efforts. I had tried to make the point during the panel that I’m not building community, I’m supporting community. There’s plenty of community happening already, I said. Why should I try to recreate the wheel? When I say that I “build community”, this audience especially would have assumed that I was responsible for setting up “corporate communities”.


Guy Kawasaki, not at all surprisingly, was a terrific keynote speaker. He used his typical top 10 list, so that if he sucks, you’ll know how much longer he’s going to suck (as he put it).


His 10 points (plus a bonus) about “Selling the Dream” – being an evangelist. He was completely on target, and they’re the rules I live by.



  1. Make Meaning

  2. Niche Thyself

  3. Don’t Be Paranoid

  4. Localize the Pain

  5. Let 100 flowers bloom

  6. Look for agnostics, not atheists

  7. Enable Test Drives

  8. Provide a Slippery Slope

  9. Make them feel a part of the team

  10. Don’t ask anyone to do something you wouldn’t

  11. Be a mensch

Both Ben and Jackie from Church of the Customer were terrific speakers, and great folks. Michael from GM was hilarious.  The BuzzMetrics folks were good people, each and every one impressed the hell out of me. Dave Evans from GSD&M nailed his presentation.


But Jim Nail from Forrester made me want to kiss him when he refuted the point that there should be a VP of WOM. Instead, he made the point that there should be a VP of Customer Advocacy, covering a number of areas. This would mark a significant change in company mindset, and not just taking this community/WOM thing and shove it into the mold of all other marketing programs.


The guy from Brand Autopsy was wearing a white lab coat, helping to cement his site in my mind. I don’t remember his name, but I certainly remember his site. Over on the site, there’s a great recap of the Keynote from Emanuel Rosen?s keynote. UPDATE: More on the dude in the lab coat.


If I don’t hear the term “Word-of-Mouth” for a year, I’ll be a happy man.


Dave Evans made a great great point that brands can’t outsource their WOM or viral campaigns entirely. Certainly they can get help in creating strategy and the implementation, but outsourcing the work doesn’t equate to turning over the keys to the house and leaving town. As Dave said, there WOM manager is the product brand manager.


George Silverman was a terrific speaker and a great magician. He told me at one point that he was so happy, after 35 years screaming about this idea of companies talking with consumers and putting the concepts of WOM to work, people are finally listening. If you ever run into George, convince him to do a card trick or even better, the rope trick.


More later!

I’m back, baby!

After a badly delayed flight out of Chicago, I’m home from the WOMMA Summit. It was a terrific couple of days, with an amazing amount of knowledge. And a unlike some previous conferences I’ve been to, everyone I met was geniunely interesting and on top of their game.


I’m going to be posting a my notes throughout the next few days. In the meantime, here’s a few links to other bloggers talking about the Summit.


 

The failings of that community thing

March 28th, 2005 | Comments | Posted in Building Community

Lee over at commoncraft.com has posted a great review of the online community business.



 The term ?online community? has gotten a bad rap in the business world since the late 90?s and I think I know why.


?Community? was held up as a cornerstone of online businesses in the late 90?s. Influential books like Net Gain got executives excited about all the possibilities. The thought was that the Web would enable communities of loyal customers to form and once they do — the cash would start rolling in. Or so they thought.


In the aftermath, ?online community? has become a bad word- something that has come to mean ?something we tried in 1998 that didn?t work.? The reputation was well earned in a lot of situations.


As I said in the comments,  I think that the biggest reason that “community” failed in circa-1998 was that businesses were using their 1980 business mindsets to approach community. Most community was thought to happen on the corporate Web site, not where the people actually already were (which was rarely on the corporate site). When no one showed up, they assumed that community didn’t work, rather than understanding that like real estate, it’s all about the location, location, location.


I think that we have a better platform (and more importantly the right mindset) for helping to build community now, at least in theory. I think that businesses are starting to understand that they need dedicated people, who understand community, and are willing to go to them, rather than forcing them to come to the corporation.


At least I’d like to hope so…

Off to Chicago!

March 28th, 2005 | Comments | Posted in Events and Speaking

I’m headed out in a little while for Chicago, where I’m attending and speaking at the WOMMA Summit. Should be a great time. There’s quite a few attendees that I’m excited to meet in person, and I’m looking forward to nearly all of the sessions. Only problem with great conferences like this – how to pick between two interesting sessions both happening at the same time.


Blogging will be light until I return. So in the meantime, here’s a question for you, gentle reader:


- Can Word of Mouth be created or managed by a company? If so, is that “real” WOM?

New books!

March 27th, 2005 | Comments | Posted in Books, Movies, TV

I unexpectedly received a copy of Seth Godin’s new book All Marketers Are Liars. Seth’s books are always worth reading and I’m looking forward to this one, although I’m having a hard time getting into the concept. We’ll see what happens after reading the book.


I also won a copy of Beyond the Brand by John Windsor from his Audible contest. I’ve been having a hard time getting into the Blink, and after flipping through this book, I’m aleady captivated. I’m off to the WOMMA Summit tomorrow and this is the book I’m taking to read on the plane! Thanks John!


 

Rule: Answer the pointless questions

March 26th, 2005 | Comments | Posted in Tricks of the Trade

As a community manager, you’re on the front lines. Assuming you’re doing things right and opening up the lines of communication, you have questions coming at you all the time.

Sometimes these questions are regarding major issues, but most of the time the questions you’ll get are minor. Well, minor to you and your colleagues, but important to the community member.

It’s easy to blow off these minor questions as "irrelevant". But in many ways, answering the minor questions is as important as dealing with the big issues.

Everyone expects you to be there when something big goes down. To not deal with the big issues is nearly negligent. But how many companies respond one-on-one to the small questions? Not that many – which is why it’s such a big boost to your company if you do.

Friday Finds

March 25th, 2005 | Comments | Posted in Fun Finds

It’s been quite a week for community around the Web. I’ve found a bunch of stuff of interest throughout the week and I’ve been too busy to do anything buy collect. So without further ado…



 

Doing it right

March 25th, 2005 | Comments | Posted in Doing It Right

After my rant about the eBay spoof auto-reply email, Jeff followed up with an example of a good response.


Thanks, Jeff!